Table of contents
Have you ever wondered if life insurance is truly worth the investment? Whether you’re considering it to protect your family, pay off debts, or plan for the future, life insurance can feel like both a practical necessity and a financial commitment. But how do you decide if it’s right for you?
This post will help you answer that question by exploring the value of life insurance in Canada. We’ll examine the two main types—term life insurance and permanent life insurance—and break down when each might be worth it and when it might not. Along the way, you’ll discover real-life scenarios, key factors to consider, and insights into how life insurance can align with your financial goals.
By the end, you’ll have a clearer understanding of whether life insurance is the right choice for your unique needs. Let’s get started!
- Key takeaways:
- Factors such as having dependents, significant debts, and the cost of life insurance play a key role in deciding whether it is worth it.
- From young families needing income replacement to retirees managing tax liabilities, the need for life insurance depends on your unique life stage and financial priorities.
- Single individuals with no dependents or couples with sufficient savings might find limited value in purchasing life insurance.
Is Term Life Insurance Worth It?
Life insurance is a financial safety net that ensures your loved ones are taken care of if you pass away. When you purchase a policy, the insurance company pays out a tax-free lump sum benefit to your beneficiaries. This money can provide financial relief, allowing your family to maintain their lifestyle, pay off debts like a mortgage, or cover other expenses.
Life insurance is especially important for people with families, significant debt, or business responsibilities. For example, business owners can use life insurance to protect their company, ensuring financial stability if they or a business partner die.
For most people, term life insurance is the most suitable option. It’s more affordable than permanent life insurance, and you can secure a large amount of coverage for a relatively low cost. Term life insurance allows you to choose both the coverage amount and the term length, with premiums guaranteed to stay the same during the term. Common term lengths are 10, 20, or 30 years, though terms can range from 5 to 50 years.
The amount of coverage you need depends on your personal and financial situation. In general, it’s recommended to have enough to pay off debts and replace your income, ensuring your family isn’t under financial strain if you pass away.
Once the term ends, you have the option to renew the policy, but the cost increases significantly. The higher premiums combined with often diminished insurance needs lead most to let the policy lapse or cancel it.
When term life insurance is worth it
Term life insurance is an excellent choice for many people because it provides high coverage at an affordable price during the years you need it most. It’s designed to protect your loved ones financially, offering peace of mind without requiring a significant financial commitment. Here are some scenarios where term life insurance proves its value:
1. The young family with dependents
A young couple with two small children, supported primarily by one parent’s income while the other manages the household, faces significant financial vulnerability. For them, a term life insurance policy is undoubtedly worth it. The lump sum benefit can cover daily living expenses, eliminate the mortgage burden, and fund future needs like college tuition, ensuring the family’s continued stability.
2. The person with significant debts
Consider an individual with a mortgage, credit card debt, line of credit, and car loan. If they were to pass away, their loved ones might be left to shoulder these debts. A term life insurance policy ensures these obligations are covered, freeing the family from financial strain and allowing them to keep their home without added worry.
3. The business with a key partner
For business owners, term life insurance can be a critical tool for protecting their company. Imagine two business partners running a successful startup. If one partner passes away, the other may struggle to keep the business running while dealing with the financial fallout.
A term life policy can provide funds to buy out the deceased partner’s share, cover operational costs, or repay business loans, ensuring the company’s survival.
In these scenarios, term life insurance is worth it because it aligns with the financial realities of these people. It’s affordable, customizable, and provides coverage during life’s most critical years. Whether you’re protecting your family, paying off debts, or ensuring your business thrives, term life insurance delivers financial security when it matters most.
When term life insurance is not worth it
While term life insurance is an excellent tool for many, it’s not always the right fit for everyone. In certain situations, paying premiums for coverage might not align with your financial needs or goals. Here are a few scenarios where term life insurance may not be worth it:
1. The financially independent spouse
Consider a couple where both partners have high-earning careers and substantial savings. They’ve already built a strong financial foundation, with no mortgage and significant retirement accounts.
If one spouse passes away, the surviving spouse can comfortably maintain their lifestyle without needing life insurance to provide income replacement. In this case, their financial independence acts as a form of self-insurance.
2. The single person with no dependents
A single individual with no dependents may not find much value in term life insurance. Since there are no financial obligations that would transfer to loved ones or dependents, there’s little need for the income replacement life insurance provides.
A single individual with no dependents may not find much value in term life insurance. Since there are no financial obligations that would transfer to loved ones or dependents, there’s little need for the income replacement life insurance provides.
Is Permanent Life Insurance Worth It?
Permanent life insurance provides coverage for your entire lifetime, making it a versatile tool for long-term financial planning. It’s essential for goals like estate planning, leaving a legacy to charity or your children, covering taxes triggered at death, or paying final expenses such as funeral costs and probate fees.
Many permanent life insurance policies also include an investment component that allows you to build cash value on a tax-deferred basis. This cash value can be accessed in the future to supplement retirement income, fund major expenses, or provide liquidity during emergencies.
There are different types of permanent life insurance to choose from, including:
- Term-100: Offers lifetime coverage with no cash value, focusing on a guaranteed death benefit at the lowest cost.
- Whole life: Combines lifetime coverage with guaranteed cash value growth and the potential for dividends, depending on the policy.
- Universal life: Provides flexible premiums and investment options, allowing you to tailor the policy to your financial needs.
Each type has unique features, such as increasing cash value and death benefits, shorter payment periods, or purely focusing on the death benefit without cash value. The right choice depends on your financial goals and how you plan to use the policy over time.
When permanent life insurance is worth it
Permanent life insurance can be a valuable financial tool for individuals with specific needs that extend beyond basic income replacement. It provides lifetime coverage, often with additional benefits like tax-advantaged cash value growth, making it an excellent option in the following scenarios:
1. The retirees with significant assets
For retirees with large RRSP or RRIF balances or substantial unrealized capital gains, the tax bill at death can significantly reduce the value of the estate left for their children.
A permanent life insurance policy can ensure that these taxes are covered without forcing heirs to sell off assets like family homes or investments. By funding the policy during their lifetime, retirees can preserve their estate and pass it intact to their loved ones.
2. The high-income earner or shareholder of a private corporation
High-income earners often max out traditional tax-sheltered accounts like RRSPs or TFSAs. Additionally, because private corporations don’t have access to these accounts, their investment income is taxed at the highest corporate rates.
Permanent life insurance offers a unique solution: they can overfund the policy, building cash value that grows tax-deferred. Later, they can access this cash value during retirement to supplement their income or meet other financial goals. For those in high tax brackets, this strategy can provide a significant long-term advantage compared to fully taxable investments.
While not a primary retirement vehicle, permanent life insurance can be a supplementary tool for specific situations, not as a replacement for traditional retirement accounts.
3. The high-net-worth parent or grandparent
Parents or grandparents can use permanent life insurance to create a lasting financial legacy. By purchasing a policy on their children or grandchildren, they can lock in lower premiums and allow the policy’s cash value to grow significantly over time.
When the children or grandchildren reach adulthood, the policy may offer them substantial cash value for their own financial needs, such as buying a home or funding education.
4. The couple with a disabled child
For parents of a disabled child who will require lifelong care, permanent life insurance can be a critical part of their financial plan. A policy can fund a trust that provides continuous financial support for the child after the parents are gone, ensuring their long-term well-being.
Unlike simple income replacement, this approach ensures that a vulnerable dependent has the resources they need for housing, medical care, and other essential services for the rest of their life.
The value of permanent life insurance depends on factors such as your tax rate, the expected growth of the policy’s cash value, your risk tolerance, and how it compares to a fully taxable alternative investment.
An in-depth analysis is crucial to determine whether permanent life insurance is the better choice for achieving your long-term financial goals.
When permanent life insurance is not worth it
While permanent life insurance offers valuable benefits in certain situations, it’s not always the best option. For many, its higher premiums and long-term commitment may not align with their financial goals or needs. Here are scenarios where permanent life insurance may not be ideal:
1. The young couple with a limited budget
A young couple in their late 20s or early 30s is just starting their careers. They have some student loan debt, are saving for a down payment on a house, and are thinking about starting a family.
This couple’s primary need is income replacement for a defined period—while raising children and paying off a mortgage. Term life insurance is a more practical solution, offering sufficient coverage at a fraction of the cost of permanent insurance.
With a limited budget, they’re better off focusing on building an emergency fund, paying off debt, and saving for their near-term goals rather than committing to the higher premiums of a permanent policy.
2. The individual focused on maximizing investment returns
Cash value growth in permanent life insurance is usually conservative due to a heavy reliance on bonds and limited investment in higher-return assets such as stocks and real estate.
While the tax-deferral feature of permanent life insurance is appealing, the returns generally won’t outperform a diversified stock portfolio over the long term, even when accounting for the tax drag on non-registered investments.
For someone with a higher risk tolerance aiming to maximize returns, term life insurance combined with investing the savings from lower premiums into higher-growth vehicles is often a more effective strategy.
3. The business owner with a loan
A business owner takes out a 10-year loan to expand their operations and wants to ensure it’s paid off if they die during the loan term.
The need for coverage is tied to a specific, predictable event: the repayment of the 10-year loan. A 10-year term life insurance policy matches this need perfectly, providing coverage during the loan term and expiring afterward.
A permanent policy, on the other hand, would extend coverage well beyond the loan period, incurring significantly higher premiums for benefits the business owner doesn’t require.
These scenarios emphasize the importance of aligning the type of life insurance with the specific need and timeframe. When the need is temporary or tied to a specific event, term life insurance is almost always the more efficient and cost-effective choice.
Permanent life insurance is better suited for long-term needs like estate planning or providing for dependents with lifelong needs, where the certainty of lifelong coverage and potential tax-advantaged growth are more valuable.
Is Life Insurance Worth It For You?
The question of whether life insurance is “worth it” is deeply personal and depends entirely on your individual circumstances. There’s no universal answer, but by considering several key factors, you can determine if it’s the right choice for you.
1. Cost and perceived value:
Cost is a crucial factor. If the premiums are unaffordable, the policy, regardless of its benefits, is simply out of reach. However, “worth” is also about perceived value. If you don’t see a significant benefit in having life insurance, even a low-cost policy might seem unnecessary. Conversely, if you highly value the peace of mind it provides, you might be willing to pay more.
For term life insurance premiums, instead of thinking of them as “wasted” if you outlive the term, consider them as payments for a vital safety net. You’re buying financial protection for your family against the risk of your premature death. Just as you pay for car insurance hoping you never need it, term life insurance provides essential protection during a specific period of your life when it’s most crucial.
2. Return on investment (ROI):
For permanent life insurance, the ROI of the cash value component is a key consideration. If you are a disciplined investor who can achieve higher returns through other investment vehicles, then the cash value component of permanent life insurance may not be worth it.
However, when comparing the cash value of permanent life insurance to alternative investments like ETFs, focus on the after-tax return since growth within the insurance policy is tax-sheltered.
A key consideration of permanent insurance is the larger estate it provides. If you die shortly after obtaining a policy, the death benefit will be far greater than the value of alternative investments made with the same premium amounts.
3. Individual circumstances:
Your personal and financial situation affect whether life insurance is worth it:
- Dependents: If you have a spouse, children, aging parents, or other dependents who depend on your income, the potential financial hardship they would face without your support makes life insurance undeniably worth it. It safeguards their financial well-being should you no longer be there.
- Financial obligations: A mortgage, significant debt (student loans, personal loans), or business ownership all increase the need for life insurance. These obligations could become a considerable burden for your family if you pass away. Conversely, life insurance is less worth it if you have sufficient assets to cover these obligations and provide for your loved ones.
- Health: While pre-existing conditions may complicate the decision due to higher premiums, the increased mortality risk they represent underscores the value of life insurance in providing financial security for loved ones.
4. Risk tolerance:
Your personal risk tolerance plays a significant role in your decision on whether term or permanent life insurance, or both, are worth it:
- Risk-averse: If you’re risk-averse and value the security of knowing your family is protected, term life insurance is well worth the premiums. Additionally, if your risk appetite limits your investment options, making it difficult to achieve returns comparable to a permanent policy’s cash value, then permanent life insurance may also become a compelling choice.
- Risk tolerant: If you are comfortable with market fluctuations and pursuing higher returns through investments, term life insurance combined with a disciplined investment strategy might be a more suitable approach.
In general, life insurance is most likely “worth it” if:
- You have dependents who rely on your financial support.
- You have significant financial obligations that could burden your loved ones.
- You are risk averse and value the certainty and peace of mind that life insurance provides for your family.
Life insurance might not be worth it if:
- You have no dependents and minimal debts.
- You have substantial assets that could easily provide for your loved ones.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is life insurance worth it in your 20s?
Life insurance may not be necessary at this stage since people often haven’t started a family or accumulated significant financial obligations. Without dependents, the primary need for life insurance—income replacement—is minimal.
However, purchasing life insurance in your 20s can have benefits. Premiums are typically lower when you’re young and healthy, allowing you to lock in an affordable rate for future coverage. This can be especially advantageous if you anticipate future needs, like starting a family or buying a home, as your health status and insurability may change over time.
Is life insurance worth it in your 30s?
For many people, their 30s mark a time of significant life changes, such as starting a family, buying a home, or advancing in their careers. These changes often come with substantial financial obligations, including a mortgage, rent, or the cost of raising children.
In this stage of life, life insurance is definitely worth it if you have dependents or financial responsibilities. Without coverage, your family could face financial strain if something were to happen to you, struggling to pay for daily expenses, debts, or future needs like your children’s education.
Is life insurance worth it in your 40s?
For many people in their 40s, life insurance is a must-have. This stage of life often comes with significant financial responsibilities, such as supporting a family, paying off a mortgage, or saving for your children’s education. If you were to pass away unexpectedly, life insurance ensures your loved ones are financially protected, helping to replace lost income and cover outstanding debts.
Additionally, life insurance rates start to increase significantly in your late 40s, reflecting the higher risk associated with age. Health issues also become more common as you approach your 50s, which could lead to rated policies (higher premiums) or even difficulty qualifying for coverage.
Is life insurance worth it in your 50s?
In your 50s, life insurance may not be as vital as it was earlier in life, depending on your financial situation. At this stage, you may be in your peak earning years, have significant savings for retirement, older or independent children, and have potentially paid down or fully paid off your mortgage. These factors can reduce the need for substantial life insurance coverage.
However, you may still require some coverage to bridge the gap until retirement or to ensure your spouse or dependents are financially secure in case of unexpected events. Additionally, if you have outstanding financial obligations, like debts or business responsibilities, or if you want to leave a financial legacy for your loved ones, life insurance can still provide valuable protection.
Is life insurance worth it in your 60s?
In your 60s, the role of life insurance often shifts from income replacement to wealth preservation and legacy planning. The need for term life insurance may decrease, as many financial responsibilities like raising children or paying off a mortgage are no longer pressing concerns. Instead, permanent life insurance may become a more suitable option depending on your goals.
Permanent life insurance can help address estate planning needs, such as covering taxes triggered at death, ensuring charitable donations, or leaving a financial legacy for your children and grandchildren. This type of coverage provides lifetime protection and can help preserve the wealth you’ve worked hard to build.
Is life insurance worth it for seniors?
For retired seniors, purchasing large amounts of life insurance can be extremely expensive due to age and increased health risks. However, there are scenarios where life insurance can still be a worthwhile consideration.
High-net-worth individuals may find permanent life insurance to be an efficient solution for estate planning. It can help cover taxes triggered at death, which can otherwise require a significant portion of assets to be liquidated. By using life insurance to cover these expenses, you can preserve your estate for heirs.
For those without large estates, smaller life insurance policies can still be valuable for covering final expenses, such as burial costs, probate fees, and funeral arrangements, ensuring these costs don’t burden your family.
Is life insurance worth it if you have no dependents?
If you don’t have dependents, life insurance may not be necessary since its primary purpose is to provide financial protection for those who rely on your income or support. Without anyone depending on you financially, the immediate need for coverage is minimal.
However, there’s a strategic benefit to consider: locking in low rates while you’re young and healthy. If you anticipate having dependents in the future, such as starting a family or supporting aging parents, purchasing life insurance now can save you money in the long run. As you get older, premiums increase, and if your health declines, coverage could become more expensive—or even unattainable.
Is life insurance worth it for a single person?
Whether life insurance is worth it for a single person depends on your unique situation. While many single individuals may not have traditional dependents, there are cases where life insurance is still valuable.
For example, if you financially support a disabled or unemployed parent, sibling, or other relative, life insurance can ensure they are taken care of if you pass away. This coverage can provide them with financial security, covering living expenses or medical care that they might otherwise struggle to afford.
Is life insurance worth it for kids?
While you may not rely on your children financially, life insurance for them can still serve valuable purposes.
One primary reason is to cover final expenses like burial and funeral costs, which can ease the financial burden during a difficult time. Having a small life insurance policy ensures these expenses are taken care of without adding stress to your family.
Another significant purpose for life insurance on children is wealth building through permanent life insurance. These policies can accumulate cash value over time, which your child can access in the future. This cash value can be used to pay for their education, as a down payment for a home, or even to supplement their retirement savings.
Is group life insurance worth it?
Group life insurance is typically offered as a benefit by your employer, though some associations also provide it to their members. A key advantage is that it can often offer more competitive rates than you could secure on an individual policy.
This is because the risk is spread across a larger group of people, lowering the cost for each individual. Therefore, enrolling in group life insurance can be a worthwhile way to obtain some level of coverage at a lower cost.
Is life insurance worth it for business owners?
In early stages or for businesses with debt or key employees, term life insurance is often essential. It can secure loans, fund buy-sell agreements, and provide a financial cushion if a key person dies.
For more established businesses with significant retained earnings, permanent life insurance offers a tax-efficient way to invest those earnings while also providing a death benefit. Thus, the value of life insurance for business owners varies based on their specific needs and business lifecycle.
Is joint first-to-die life insurance worth it?
Joint first-to-die life insurance covers two people and pays out a death benefit when the first person dies. This type of policy is particularly well-suited for covering shared debts, such as a mortgage held jointly by a couple. Upon the death of the first spouse, the payout can be used to pay off the remaining mortgage balance, relieving the surviving spouse of that financial burden.
Is joint last-to-die life insurance worth it?
Joint last-to-die life insurance covers multiple people but only pays out after the last insured person dies. Its primary use is estate preservation by covering taxes triggered when both spouses or partners pass away.
Because the payout is delayed, premiums are generally lower than insuring each person separately, making it a cost-effective tool for wealth preservation and transfer to future generations.
Your Next Steps: Deciding If Life Insurance Is Worth It
Ultimately, the question of whether life insurance is “worth it” hinges on your unique circumstances and priorities. By carefully considering the factors outlined above, you can gain valuable insight into your specific situation. Consulting with a qualified insurance advisor can further empower you to navigate this decision with confidence.
Finding the right insurance can be complex. At Brian So Insurance, we simplify the process with free, no-obligation consultations. We’ll get to know your personal and financial situation, compare options from multiple companies, help you implement your ideal insurance solution, and provide ongoing support to ensure your coverage remains the perfect fit throughout your life.
We specialize in designing complete insurance solutions, incorporating term and permanent life insurance, disability insurance, health & dental plans, and critical illness coverage.
For a personalized consultation, reach out to us today:
- Email: info@briansoinsurance.com
- Phone: 604-928-1628
Alternatively, request a free quote delivered directly to your inbox by using the form below.
Remember, a well-crafted insurance plan can provide priceless peace of mind for you and your loved ones. Don’t hesitate to take the first step towards securing your financial future.
Get Your Life Insurance Quote Now
While we make every effort to keep our site updated, please be aware that timely information on this page, such as quote estimates, or pertinent details about companies, may only be accurate as of its last edit day. Brian So Insurance and its representatives do not give legal or tax advice. Please consult your own legal or tax adviser. This post is a brief summary for indicative purposes only. It does not include all terms, conditions, limitations, exclusions, and other provisions of the policies described, some of which may be material to the policy selection. Please refer to the actual policy documents for complete details which can be provided upon request. In case of any discrepancy, the language in the actual policy documents will prevail. A.M. Best financial strength ratings displayed are not a warranty of a company’s financial strength and ability to meet its obligations to policyholders.
